Some Syllabus Language That Might Be Useful
Please feel free to incorporate the following statements in your syllabus. I had so much to learn from, among others, Lauren Alpert’s global ethics syllabus, Alison Reiheld’s feminist theory syllabus, Amy Shuster’s political and social philosophy syllabus, and so many of the syllabi shared by graduate students in the UA philosophy department. I have also added some in-text notes where relevant. If you have any feedback or suggestions for improvement, I’d love to know!
[5/21/23: I decided to remove the “crisis resources” section following disturbing reports of unwanted police intervention and forced psychiatric detention of suicide hotline callers. See, e.g., this and this.]
* * *
Table of Contents
- Respect, Support, and Care for One Another
- Student Support Resources
- (Lack of) Diversity in Philosophy
* * *
1. Respect, Support, and Care for One Another
Materials in this course
Since many of the issues we will cover in this course are not only intellectually but also personally relevant, you might find it difficult to read and discuss certain course materials. I want to acknowledge that. It’s perfectly understandable.
It’s therefore important that we respect, support, and care for one another throughout the course. Please always feel free to talk to me if you anticipate certain topics will be especially difficult for you, or if you think the way they get discussed in the class is disrespectful or otherwise problematic.
How to Respect, Support, and Care for One Another
Here are some concrete examples of how you can respect, support, and care for your classmates and instructor:
- Value everyone’s contribution to class discussions;
- Disagree in a way that takes other people’s ideas seriously and sincerely;
- Challenge remarks, jokes, and examples that are racist, sexist, heterosexist, cissexist, misogynistic, transmisogynistic, xenophobic, ableist, ageist, classist, etc.;
- Keep discussions inclusive by avoiding talking to only a few specific people;
- [For online discussion boards] Be mindful of how your tone/meaning might not be accurately conveyed through your writing alone (for example, if your question might be misunderstood as a rhetorical one, it’s probably a good idea to indicate explicitly that it is a genuine question);
- [For Zoom classes] Please use your go-by name as your Zoom display name and, if you feel comfortable and safe doing so, include your pronouns as well. [Note to instructors: It’s a good idea to avoid simply asking students to share their pronouns (e.g., “let’s go around the room and say our names and pronouns”), which could create a particularly stressful double-bind situation for trans students who are not openly out: now they have to choose between misgendering themselves or being forced to come out! It’s also useful to take note when a student changes their name or pronouns in the middle of the semester. But don’t be inquisitive and don’t make a big deal out of it; just naturally switch how you refer to the student from then on. For in-person classes, I’ve found it helpful to make it clear at the beginning of the semester that I understand people’s names and pronouns can change and invite students to inform me of any such changes if and only if they feel safe and comfortable doing so (there are too many reasons why a student may not feel safe or comfortable sharing their pronouns, so give them space and don’t blame yourself for not doing enough).]
- Try to remain quiet if you have to arrive late or leave early;
- Avoid starting to pack things up until class is completely over;
- Listen attentively and avoid distracting or interrupting behavior, such as chatting with the person next to you or checking your phone.
Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation
- Use the pronouns and name you are asked to when you refer to a person; [Note to instructors: Here too, it’s wise not to pressure students to share their pronouns. But if a student does mention what pronouns they use, make sure to use only those pronouns (e.g., the vast majority of trans people consider it misgendering to use gender-neutral pronouns to refer to a trans person who one knows uses exclusively gender-specific pronouns). If they do not share their pronouns, you can default to they/them. Be prepared that you or a student will probably slip up once in a while. When that happens, quickly correct yourself/the student and move on—don’t pretend you didn’t notice it, but also don’t overreact and especially don’t overapologize (it draws unnecessary and often unwanted attention). If a student uses more than one set of pronouns (e.g., he/they), make an effort to switch between them from time to time. Often, the primary pronouns are listed first (in this case, he/him/his), but that is not always the case; when in doubt, ask the student privately. Even though doing such little things as using the correct pronouns and names might not sound like it matters that much, it can definitely mean the whole world to a trans student. A common pitfall, however, is to overemphasize that this is something you will do, only to fail to deliver; show, don’t just tell.]
- Avoid assuming a person’s pronouns, gender identity, or sexual orientation based on their appearance, voice, or name; [Note to instructors: It’s difficult, but please try to avoid inferring a student’s gender identity solely from their pronouns. Pronouns are just one aspect of our gender expression (consider: wearing a suit doesn’t by itself imply that the person is a man, even though many men express their gender identity with a suit rather than a dress—as Leslie Feinberg puts it more elegantly than I ever could, “gender is the poetry each of us makes out of the language we are taught”). And there are good reasons—sometimes safety-related reasons—for a student to use pronouns not conventionally associated with a gender identity. Work with them; don’t police that.]
- Be careful not to disclose anyone’s gender identity or sexual orientation (i.e., out them) without their permission, even if they are already out in the classroom—it can put lives in danger;
- Never inquire about anyone’s genitalia, deadname, “before” photos, medical history, assigned gender at birth, sex life, and so on;
- Use inclusive language (for helpful examples, see https://www.apaonline.org/page/nonsexist and https://transjournalists.org/style-guide).
If you feel any aspect of this course makes it difficult for you to participate fully, I want to know. This is very important to me.
2. Student Support Resources
- Campus Health: https://health.arizona.edu
- Counseling and Psych Services (CAPS): https://health.arizona.edu/counseling-psych-services
- Mental Health Tools from CAPS: https://health.arizona.edu/mental-health-tools
- Dean of Students Office Student Assistance Services: https://deanofstudents.arizona.edu/support/student-assistance
- Survivor Advocacy: https://survivoradvocacy.arizona.edu
- Fostering Success: https://fosteringsuccess.arizona.edu
- Find Your Philosophy Advisor: https://philosophy.arizona.edu/advising
- Become a Philosophy Major: https://philosophy.arizona.edu/why-study-philosophy
- Think Tank Writing Center: https://thinktank.arizona.edu/writing-center
- Writing Skills Improvement Program: https://wsip.arizona.edu
- Campus Pantry: https://campuspantry.arizona.edu
- UA Childcare Choice Program for Students: https://lifework.arizona.edu/programs/childcare-choice/student
- List of Resources from the Office of LGBTQ Affairs: https://lgbtq.arizona.edu/students
- Disability Resource Center: https://drc.arizona.edu
3. (Lack of) Diversity in Philosophy
Unfortunately, philosophy as an institutionalized discipline is remarkably white, cis male, straight, able-bodied, and middle-class. This lack of diversity is often apparent just from the topics and authors typically taught in introductory philosophy courses. However, philosophy as a whole is becoming more and more diverse thanks to the efforts of several generations of philosophers. As a philosophy student, you can also help the profession address its diversity and inclusiveness problems by engaging with minority authors seriously and supporting your fellow minority students.
The American Philosophical Association (APA) has a useful handout for minority undergraduate students in philosophy, which you can read here: https://www.apaonline.org/resource/resmgr/diversity/Advice_for_Undergrads.pdf.
A valuable local opportunity is the Arizona Feminist Philosophy Graduate Conference organized annually by graduate students at the UA Department of Philosophy. The conference takes place in the spring semester. It brings together graduate students working on feminist issues from all around the country and the world. You can find more information and watch recordings of past talks at https://femphilaz.com.